Meeting Time: September 14, 2026 at 6:30pm PDT
The online Comment window has expired

Agenda Item

L.1. HC26-1146 RECEIVE AND FILE A PRESENTATION FROM ALLEN SANFORD REGARDING A WAVE POOL DESIGN CONCEPT AT THE SEASIDE LAGOON SITE

  • Screen_shot_2021-04-16_at_5.06.41_pm
    Niki NegreteMitchell 2 months ago

    There is so much to learn about Seaside Lagoon as a public park and the discussions from the promoters of this concept don't seem to have any interest whatsoever in figuring that out. Pitching corporate talking points and placing their spin on facts and data has more than alienated the public at large. Having been through the MASSIVE process that the Metro project entailed it's very easy to spot the holes in their talking points. Don't fall for it.

    Moving forward with Phase 1 is absolutely in the city's best interest. Placing any more delays on revitalizing the Waterfront would just cause more problems. Opening this space sooner rather than later along with all of the other Harbor amenities, including the old Fun Factory space is what will help bring patrons to visit. The replacement to the old Ruby's space, while very nice, is a bit of a disappointment since it is not so family friendly and the private club is even a bigger disappointment after all of the big, exciting promises made during its inception.

    Please think more critically about this. Listen to those with experience as they share their well informed commentary. Keep public land public. Please don't be a part of the problem.

  • Default_avatar
    Jessica Gonzales 2 months ago

    The direction the Harbor Commission appears to be taking is deeply concerning.

    The Commission had an opportunity to hear a presentation and consider ways to improve the existing Seaside Lagoon plan. Instead, you appear to be opening the door to an entirely different concept—one that has not been demonstrated to be financially viable, feasible, or approvable by the California Coastal Commission.

    That is not responsible planning. It is speculation.

    Before moving in a different direction, where are the numbers? Where is the financial analysis? Who would pay for additional design, permitting, construction, and operating costs? Has anyone determined whether this concept could actually be built and approved?

    There is already a plan that has gone through an extensive public process and has a path forward. If improvements are needed, make them. Address legitimate concerns. But pursuing an untested alternative makes little sense unless there is a specific reason for doing so.

    Residents have a right to ask what that reason is.

    The Harbor Commission should not become a vehicle for advancing interests that may benefit from delaying or reshaping this project. If there is no hidden agenda, transparency should not be difficult. Put the facts on the table. Show the studies, financial analysis, and regulatory review. Let the public judge for itself.

    Commissioners were appointed to represent the public interest—not to advance someone else's development strategy. Your obligation is to the residents of Redondo Beach and our waterfront.

    Do not let a project that can actually be accomplished become collateral damage in pursuit of a concept that exists primarily on paper.
    You should examine the existing plan and make practical improvements. If someone wants to replace it with something substantially different, they should prove through independent analysis that their proposal is actually better for Redondo Beach.

    Until then, pursuing a speculative alternative is irresponsible.

    The public is watching, and we will remember those commissioners who protected Redondo Beach residents and who took this project in another direction asking they be removed from the Harbor Commission

  • Default_avatar
    Lisa Youngworth 2 months ago

    I am at a loss as to why the Harbor Commission is not even willing to entertain this presentation.

    The Commission’s responsibility should be to review the existing plan, consider public input, and recommend reasonable improvements to the City Council. Instead, it appears the Commission is choosing to re-examine and potentially redesign a plan rather than focus on improving the plan that is already before it.

    What is particularly concerning is the consideration of a concept that appears highly speculative and would require significant changes to the existing plan, including changes that may ultimately face serious Coastal Commission obstacles. Before entertaining such a major departure, there should at minimum be a thorough economic analysis, feasibility review, and clear understanding of the regulatory requirements.

    If there are relatively minor changes that could improve the existing plan, those should be discussed and evaluated. A wholesale redesign, however, should not move forward based on speculation or without understanding its financial, environmental, regulatory, and operational consequences.

    The Harbor Commission represents the residents of Redondo Beach and has a responsibility to ensure that its decisions serve the public interest. The public deserves transparency about why the Commission is considering a fundamentally different direction and what evidence supports doing so.

    I strongly urge the Commission to return its focus to the existing plan, evaluate practical improvements, and avoid pursuing an unsubstantiated redesign that could delay the project, increase costs, or jeopardize the progress already made.

  • Default_avatar
    Carissa Robinson 2 months ago

    I understand the Harbor Commission is being asked to receive and file the wave-pool presentation. But receiving this proposal should not become a reason to delay, derail, or reopen the years of public work already invested in Phase 1.

    Phase 1 is the product of years of public participation, community input, professional planning, and significant public investment. If there are legitimate concerns about access, circulation, infrastructure, configuration, or year-round use, address them as Phase 1 moves through the entitlement process. We do not need to discard years of work to make the plan better.

    Most importantly, Seaside Lagoon is public land and a public amenity. A public park should not be judged by whether it maximizes revenue per square foot. Its value is public access, recreation, community, and providing a place that families, children, and people across income levels and abilities can enjoy.

    A privately operated commercial wave pool occupying a significant portion of this property is not simply an “ancillary amenity.” It fundamentally changes the nature and use of this public space. And commercial ventures carry commercial risk: investors leave, ownership changes, and businesses fail. Public land, however, remains a public responsibility.

    If a commercial wave pool is proposed, let it go through its own transparent public process. Study its footprint, economics, environmental impacts, public access, lease terms, and long-term risks. Let that proposal stand on its own merits.

    But do not hold Phase 1 hostage while that happens.

    Please protect the public process, the public investment, and the public nature of Seaside Lagoon. Address legitimate concerns and allow Phase 1 to keep moving forward.

  • 1889377064423124
    Claudia Berman 2 months ago

    I'm in favor of moving ahead with the state grant to renovate Seaside Lagoon. The city has already put years of work into Phase 1 of the King Harbor Amenities Plan, and a wave pool proposal that showed up late in the process without any real vetting shouldn't be given serious consideration at this stage. To start over with a wave pool, really is starting at square 1, but this time will required a CEQA process and competitive bidding.

  • 10215465780065025
    Lezlie Campeggi 2 months ago

    The Harbor Commission made a recommendation to NOT approve the design of Phase I of the King Harbor Amenities Plan and to ask City Council for a "do-over." You asked for more public input, ignoring the fact that there was major public input for several years, along with stakeholders, facilitated by SWA with whom the city contracted. It's fine for the Commission to have a different opinion. It's reasonable to have been confused by some of the components in the Staff presentation that night as it and their answers to your questions were less than articulate in many areas. They also answered "I don't know" to at least one question; something that should not happen at this stage.

    At the end of the meeting, you asked for a referral to Staff to agendize presentations that would offer solutions to the Lagoon being open 365 days per year. Then you specifically moved to agendize the presentation tonight for a wave pool. And this is where you went off track.

    To ask for an unvetted, competing proposal to a current City Council-approved project phase is circumventing the Council. The Council has not directed ANY solicitation for new proposals. To do so requires a procedural process to define scope, write an RFP, post, invite bidders, in a 100% full and transparent process. The City Council is not allowed to sole-source ANY project plan. But this Commission has bypassed that process by inviting a presenter to outline a "vision" for changing a Regional State Park, in the Coastal Zone, that would not pass scrutiny with the California Coastal Commission who holds jurisdiction for development permits.

    You've done a major disservice by hosting this, one day before the Council rules on Phase I, and without their direction to re-open this Phase. Many in the public have no idea that the wave pool "vision" exceeds the Lagoon boundaries, doesn't conform to Measure C, our LCP, and that the law does not allow for the Lagoon to shrink in size. Shame on this commission for facilitating a presentation for a "vision" inconsistent and incompatible with the laws governing this public parkland. You should be taking time to educate what's possible, not promote what is not.

  • 8671796982839587
    Nainsi Skiba 2 months ago

    Please approve municipal Phase 1 modernization for Seaside Lagoon this Tuesday. Under Measure C and our certified Local Coastal Program, our sovereign public parkland cannot be shrunk or privatized. Do not stall three years of completed engineering and $10 million in secured public funding for speculative commercial wave pool concepts. Keep Seaside Lagoon 100% public."

  • 10216707516576169
    Anneke Blair 2 months ago

    While tonight’s item is a receive-and-file presentation with no formal action, your discussion establishes the official public record. As fiduciaries of our tidelands, your duty during this discussion is to demand hard, forensic answers rather than allowing promotional sales claims to pass unchallenged.

    A commercial wave pool charging $150 to $200 per hour is not public park modernization. It is an exclusive privatization scheme that carries serious legal, coastal, and financial risks.

    During your discussion tonight, I urge the Commission to ask the proponents these four fundamental questions:

    Measure C & Water Footprint: How can this concept legally proceed when voter-approved Measure C and our certified Local Coastal Program strictly prohibit shrinking our public water feature or reducing open parkland? Paywalling off 70% of sovereign water for a private pay-to-play pool directly violates that mandate.

    The Capital Stack & Taxpayer Risk: What is the actual, verified capital stack? Will proponents legally guarantee and indemnify Redondo Beach taxpayers against site preparation costs, utility infrastructure upgrades, operating shortfalls, and decommissioning liabilities if the business fails?

    Targeting the Public Grant: Proponents openly state on their promotional website that they intend to utilize the City's $10 million state grant. Under what legal authority could state grant funds awarded specifically for an open, affordable, 100% public park be transferred or diverted to subsidize a private commercial club?

    Independent Economic Proof: Where is the independent, audited fiscal analysis supporting the claim of $1 million in annual City tax revenue? What public costs, fee waivers, or infrastructure subsidies must be deducted to arrive at a true net benefit?Until legally binding, audited answers exist, calling a private wave pool the "highest and best use" of sovereign tidelands is a sales pitch. You must also ask: "highest and best use" for whom? The most profitable use for an outside private entity is rarely the best public use.

    Please reaffirm that Seaside Lagoon must remain 100% public under Measure C.

    Modernize, don't privatize.

  • Default_avatar
    Darryl Boyd 2 months ago

    Move ahead with Phase 1. Allen Sanford a non Resident of this City must not be allowed to take over & monetize our public property. The Seaside Lagoon is not Allen Sanford's private empire. This is elitism & an unwanted members only class being installed in Redondo Beach by Sanford. This is NOT Redondo Beach values & he must be stopped from running a monopoly in our Marina. NO TO SANFORD!

  • 129250022986227
    Barbara Epstein 2 months ago

    As one who participated in nearly all public King Harbor Amenities Plan meetings and appreciated the work of the SWA landscape consultants, I must oppose the wave machine at this time. I support solving the technical execution problems I see in the first phase, then going ahead with the improved Phase One Plan. I would appreciate a public meeting to refine those details.
    There is no room in the Seaside Lagoon for further elements to be added.
    I support year round use of the Lagoon as a public access venue. This past Saturday I thought the Water event provided an example of appropriate public use there.
    For the record, I am always opposed to public land, especially parkland, to be privatized for commercial gain,.
    If the community agrees, considering a wave feature could be considered in the future, depending upon full disclosure.

  • Default_avatar
    Jill Klausen 2 months ago

    I am deeply opposed to consideration of turning over public land to for-profit developer Alan Sanford to create an unneeded wave pool that will only be accessible to wealthy people who can afford the $100-200 hourly cost while shrinking the available space that families can enjoy for their $10 entry fee. This would be a grotesque abuse of public resources at best, and at worst would cost us the remainder of the $10 million state grant given to Redondo Beach for Phase 1 of the lagoon improvement project.

    It's long past time to stop the corrupt corporate takeover of Redondo Beach before we lose everything that makes us a beloved destination for the whole of Los Angeles to enjoy.

    Jill Klausen
    Redondo Beach resident since 1994

  • Default_avatar
    Steve Randall 2 months ago

    This is so disturbing to see. The city picked a facilitator to conduct a process for the public and business owners and anyone who wanted to participate to be part of developing the King Harbor Amenities Plan. It took several years. The Harbor Commission has problems with the plan for the Seaside Lagoon not meeting their expectations. Why didn't they give some solutions to fix Phase I? This isn't a new topic for them. Where have they been? Instead, they suddenly want to blow it all up and showcase somebody's plan to takeover our public parkland! Fix what needs to be fixed per what the public decided, for public property! A wave pool? Seriously? By the beach? What kind of presentation are they going to ask for at their next meeting for a project they have no authority to decide on? Do your job Harbor Commissioners. Give your detailed suggestions on how to fix Phase I to address the concerns you have while understanding it's not your decision to change the plan. No to this attempted coup for a private party to control the majority of the Seaside Lagoon. No to the wave pool.

  • 2662252467562986
    Ira Ellman 2 months ago

    I support moving forward with utilizing the state grant to renovate the Seaside Lagoon. Redondo Beach has spent years on Phase 1 of the King Harbor Amenities Plan. A last minute, unvetted and out of nowhere plan for a wave pool should not even be considered. In addition, charging $100-$250 per hour for surfing doesn’t seem like something that should be charged for use on public lands This space is a State Regional Park located on state tidelands and controlled by the State Lands Commissions and California Coastal Commission. This treasure in Redondo Beach is utilized by families and kids’ camps. After the renovation, it seems possible to open the space year round.

  • 1270382153946923
    Ronnie Brooks 2 months ago

    I am a Redondo Beach resident writing to oppose the private “Ocean Park” wave pool proposal. Please place this letter in the official public record.
    Outside developers and surf advocates do not speak for residents who live here, pay local taxes, face local traffic, and bear the consequences of this project.

    Calling it a “public park destination” does not change its nature: a commercial wave facility on coastal land. Promised tax revenue and community benefits are marketing claims, not evidence or resident consent.

    Before any approval or agreement, the City must require:
    • Full CEQA review of traffic, noise, lighting, water and energy use, coastal impacts, emissions, safety, and cumulative impacts.
    • Compliance with the Coastal Act, Local Coastal Program, zoning, and public-access laws.
    • Independent fiscal review of costs, infrastructure, maintenance, insurance, emergency services, revenue, and taxpayer risk.
    • Disclosure of leases, subsidies, revenue sharing, exclusivity, naming rights, and private benefits.
    • Public participation before commitments limit alternatives.
    • Enforceable, affordable public access, not a costly reservation-based tourist attraction.

    Claims about “community impact,” business benefits, or tax revenue must be independently verified and guaranteed by contract. Residents should not carry the risks while a private operator profits. Coastal public land should serve broad local needs, not a specialized interest promoted by outside groups or an experimental business.

    I urge the Council to reject Ocean Park. At minimum, take no action until required reviews are complete, agreements are disclosed, and residents have a binding role in the site’s future.

    We live here, pay for City decisions, and face the traffic, noise, environmental harm, and financial risk after outside interests leave. Our voices must carry more weight than a private marketing campaign. We do not need or want this project.

    Please represent Redondo Beach residents and say no.

    Respectfully,
    Ronnie Brooks
    Redondo Beach Resident

  • Default_avatar
    Mark Nelson 2 months ago

    Oppose considering this significant change for Phase 1. Phase 1 has spent about $3M in planning and have about $7M left for execution. It's time of freeze the scope in place (except perhaps for 2050 sea level rise issues) and move with the existing funding on the existing project. Any consideration of a wave pool rightly belongs in Phase 2 or later. At this time, the City does not have the internal skills to manage a wave pool and concession and without sponsorships and concession the small wave pool is not cost-effective for City ownership.